Helping Employee Health and Benefits Insurance Account Managers Shift from Service to Revenue Focus: A Step-by-Step Guide

In the competitive world of small-group health insurance, account managers have traditionally been the backbone of customer satisfaction — handling service issues, answering coverage questions, and ensuring that clients remain loyal year after year. However, as the industry evolves and margins tighten, there is a growing need for account managers to shift their focus from purely servicing clients to actively contributing to revenue growth.

This transition isn't just about adding sales goals to a service role. It requires a strategic change in mindset, skills, daily activities, and support structures. Here's how you can help your account managers successfully make this critical shift.

Step 1: Redefine the Role Expectations

The first step is clarity. Leadership must redefine the role of the account manager not just as a client advocate but as a business growth partner. New expectations should include:

• Identifying upsell and cross-sell opportunities.
• Educating clients about new products and solutions.
• Renewing accounts with a focus on increasing group participation.
• Bringing consultative value that ties directly to client business outcomes.

Action Tip: Create updated job descriptions that emphasize revenue responsibilities alongside service expectations.

Step 2: Provide Sales Training and Tools

Many service-focused account managers lack formal sales training. Provide:

• Consultative selling skills workshops.
• Product training so account managers can confidently recommend additional coverage (e.g., dental, vision, life, voluntary benefits).
• CRM tools that track client activities, renewal timelines, and pipeline opportunities.

Action Tip: Pair account managers with experienced sales mentors for coaching.

Step 3: Adjust KPIs and Incentive Structures

You get the behavior you reward. Transition performance metrics from only service-focused KPIs (like issue resolution time) to include revenue-focused KPIs, such as:

• Retention rates.
• Revenue per group.
• Cross-sell/upsell ratios.

Incentives should align with these new KPIs — think bonus structures based on revenue growth and client satisfaction.

Step 4: Reframe Client Conversations

Service conversations tend to be reactive (e.g., "You have an issue? I'll fix it.”) whereas revenue-focused conversations are proactive:

• Explore business goals: "What are your company's growth plans next year?"
• Identify gaps: "Are your employees asking about other benefits?"
• Position solutions: "Based on what you've shared, a wellness program could help reduce absenteeism."

Action Tip: Equip account managers with conversation guides and question frameworks.

Step 5: Build a Feedback Loop

As account managers grow into their new role, regular check-ins are essential. Managers should:

• Review revenue activities in one-on-ones.
• Celebrate small wins early and often.
• Address obstacles like pricing issues, underwriting delays, or gaps in product knowledge.

Action Tip: Create a real-time dashboard showing revenue-related activities and outcomes.

A Day in the Life: Before and After the Shift

‍

Final Thoughts

The future of account management in small-group health insurance lies in blending service excellence with strategic revenue growth. By thoughtfully evolving the account manager's role, offering the right training and support, and shifting incentives, your organization can create a team of client partners who drive satisfaction and bottom-line success.
‍

The key is patience — culture change takes time — but with clear steps and a commitment to growth, your account managers can thrive in this new, more impactful role.